|
|
|
Author |
Message |
BRN (Unregistered Guest) Unregistered guest Posted From:
| Posted on Wednesday, April 11, 2007 - 11:22 am: |
|
Here is a little thing I did this afternoon. It's not big deal but is a bit interesting if you are struggling with noun gender. Since there are many variables, I decided to look at a sample of a few hundred nouns from all declensions (bar irregular) and see what came out. 5 general grades for placing a noun: Functional class (abstractnoun ; object/concreate; mass; body) Strongish tendency for functonal class to override other condiderations Actor class (family, profession, characters) Natural gender very strong Nominal class (names) Actor gender, very very likely to override Suffix class (óg etc) Determining Phonotactic class (final vowel, polarity of consonant) Very strong where nouns have been rationalised What this suggested that a noun was determined by a number of factors which must be condidered together (no shock there) |
|
BRN (Unregistered Guest) Unregistered guest Posted From:
| Posted on Wednesday, April 11, 2007 - 11:26 am: |
|
Its all a bit messy, but in more depth: Rules (read: tendencies): Functional class: abstract nouns like anger (i.e. non-projecable into direct imagry) are mostly feminine concreate nouns like cat (i.e. projectable into direct imagry) are mostly masculine mass nouns like rain and sea (massivly parallel entities composed of ‘submerged’ conponents) tend towards feminine body nouns like hand, eye etc that are composit entities or part of a larger part (arm, face) are feminine Actor class: Family member nouns tend to follow the natural gender of the actor (mother =feminine, father =masculine) very strongly Profession nouns are mostly ending in clear markers (long vowel and final r) and for historical reasons are felt to be masculine. Where women predominate, natural gender means nouns are feminine (banaltra) Óir Bádóir Boatman Eoir Feirmeoir Farmer (a)ire Cabaire Chatterer (a)í Scéalaí Storyteller éir búistéir butcher Characters are gendered based on suffixes and natural gender and phonotactics (that is, contextually) Nominal class: Personal first names go with the natural gender of the person (or pet!) Surnames change based on the gender pre-fix (Ó, Ní etc) and other declensionary considerations not relivant here Suffix class: masculine (as, adh, án, an, ín) altho it has to be said that only ín is productive, so they could have gone into the phonotactic set feminine (óg, eog, íocht, lann) Phonotactic class: Masculine (Most general rule: broad final consonant; no data for o and u) á ó ú í e i a in short nouns ach in monosylables ach in derivatives (e)adh moladh praise (e)adh moladh praise (e)amh caitheamh spending ás sólás solace/consolation úr casúr hammer ún naisiún nation éad firéad ferret éal buidéal bottle éar suipéar supper (e)ad droichead bridge ar bór road ste óraiste orange Feminine (Most general rule: slender final consonant; No data on short o and u). é bé maid (e) acht (2+ syllables) cláirseach harp seach móiréis haughtiness áil(t) spáráil sparing aíl feadaíl whistling (a) irt bagairt threat (a) ilt meilt griding (a) int caint talking ís mailís malice áid úsáid usage óid liathróid ball |
|
BRN (Unregistered Guest) Unregistered guest Posted From:
| Posted on Wednesday, April 11, 2007 - 11:28 am: |
|
Finally, a quick test based on the rules: cable cábla ; slabhra english loan word; concreate noun; bi-syllabic; final a MASC cache folachán final án suffix MASC calculation áireamh ; comhaireamh somewhat abstract; braod ending; amh ending MASC calculator áireamhán án suffix MASC calculus calcalas name of subject; as ending MASC calendar féilire concreate object with nuaces of abstract; ire ending MASC 6/6 camomile fíogadán ; camán ;[camomile tea tae fíogadáin] án suffix MASC camouflage ceileatram ; braod ending; ‘concreate feature’ or secondary feature of an object MASC duaithníocht ; íocht final suffix FEM camp campa ; short noun plus a final; disyllabic MASC campáil long vowel followed by final slender consonant FEM longfort ; final broad cluster with broad r MASC 6/6 Cancer an Portán Final án MASC candidate iarrthtóir óir is a profession suffix MASC 2/2 cannabis cannabas ending is –as MASC cannibal canablach 2+ syllables ending in ach FEM cannon canónach 2+ syllables ending in ach FEM capital city príomhchathair final slender r and short vowel MASC capitalism caipitleachas final –as MASC 2/5 captive cime ; captive is a concreate entity; final front e MASC daor final r with long prior vowel MASC géibheannach long word woth final ach FEM captivity géibheann final broad consonat; contains long vowel and fricaitve NOT SURE; FEM carbon carbón long vowel and final braod n MASC carburettor carbradóir profession ending MASC carcass conablach ach at end on 3 syllabic noun FEM 4/7 24 noun sample No correct based on rules: 20 Some observations: adjectives needed to be learned (and considered) as they can confuse analysis; final long consonants such as –ill, inn heavily weight towards feminine, as does final long nn and ll for masculine. The rule for –ach with 2 or more syllables is frequently over ridden when a noun is very ‘unfeminine’ in its referent While a very small sample, a success rate of +80% is encouraging |
|
|
|