A Chairde,
Here is a link to an article entitled "Irish Language Use in the Community and Family Domains in Two Gaeltacht Areas: A Comparative Analysis" by Rachele Antonini.
It compares the Galway and Donegal situations and what I got from it was that Galway seems to be in somewhat better shape than the county to the north.
http://www.dur.ac.uk/dwp.linguistics/resources/DWPVOL8/DWP8Antonini.pdf It's unfortunate that Mr Ó Siadhail had to select the idiosyncratic Cois Fhairrge dialect rather than the speech of Carna-Carraroe-Casla, as that variety seems to be more viable. I have the impression that Irish is not in good shape in the area from Spiddal to Casla. Am I mistaken?